Pro-Israel lobby

U.S.-Israel-Arab interests
In December 2002, Kathleen McGrath Christison and William Christison wrote in CounterPunch:


 * "...policymaking circles throughout government now no longer even make a pretense of exhibiting balance between Israeli and Arab, particularly Palestinian, interests.


 * "In the Clinton administration, the three most senior State Department officials dealing with the Palestinian-Israeli peace process were all partisans of Israel to one degree or another. One of these officials had worked both as a pro-Israel lobbyist and as director of a pro-Israel think tank in Washington before taking a position in the Clinton administration from which he helped make policy on Palestinian-Israeli issues. Another has headed the pro-Israel think tank since leaving government.


 * "The link between active promoters of Israeli interests and policymaking circles is stronger by several orders of magnitude in the Bush administration, which is peppered with people who have long records of activism on behalf of Israel in the United States, of policy advocacy in Israel, and of promoting an agenda for Israel often at odds with existing U.S. policy. These people, who can fairly be called Israeli loyalists, are now at all levels of government, from desk officers at the Defense Department to the deputy secretary level at both State and Defense, as well as on the National Security Council staff and in the vice president's office.

In January 2004, the Sydney Morning Herald (Australia) reported that the European Union's executive commission "reacted with fury to accusations of anti-Semitism by two leading Jewish groups, saying criticism of Israel had nothing to do with hostility to Jews."


 * "...The accusations, made by the heads of the World Jewish Congress and the European Jewish Congress and published in the Financial Times on Monday, were discussed at length at the commission's first meeting of the year, a commission spokesman, Reijo Kemppinen, said on Wednesday. ...


 * "...The commission strongly rejected allegations that legitimate criticism by EU institutions of the actions of Israel had anything to do with anti-Semitism, he said. 'These two things are separate.'"

"The power and influence of major U.S. Jewish organisations owe a lot to the convergence of their views with the neo-conservative elements who dominate the ruling coalition in Washington," India's Frontline magazine commented in 2003.

Left criticism
Former CIA analysts, Kathleen and Bill Christison, argue that left criticism of the Israel Lobby is "coming chiefly from Noam Chomsky and Norman Finkelstein, and abetted less cogently by Stephen Zunes of Foreign Policy in Focus and Joseph Massad of Columbia University." They go on to note that:
 * "The principal problem with these arguments from the left is that they assume a continuity in U.S. strategy and policymaking over the decades that has never in fact existed. The notion that there is any defined strategy that links Eisenhower's policy to Johnson's to Reagan's to Clinton's gives far more credit than is deserved to the extremely ad hoc, hit-or-miss nature of all U.S. foreign policy. Obviously, some level of imperial interest has dictated policy in every administration since World War II and, obviously, the need to guarantee access to vital natural resources around the world, such as oil in the Middle East and elsewhere, has played a critical role in determining policy. But beyond these evident, and not particularly significant, truths, it can accurately be said, at least with regard to the Middle East, that it has been a rare administration that has itself ever had a coherent, clearly defined, and consistent foreign policy and that, except for a broadly defined anti-communism during the Cold War, no administration's strategy has ever carried over in detail to succeeding administrations."

And note that: "Today, even the most outspoken of leftist radio hosts and other commentators, such as Randi Rhodes, Mike Malloy, and now Cindy Sheehan, almost always avoid talking and writing about this issue."

The Christisons also add that:


 * "Indeed, far from Israel functioning as the junior partner carrying out a U.S. plan, it is clear that the weight of pressure in 1967 was on the U.S. to go along with Israel's designs and that this pressure came from Israel and its agents in the U.S. The lobby in this instance as broadly defined by Mearsheimer and Walt: "the loose coalition of individuals and organizations who actively work to shape U.S. foreign policy in a pro-Israel direction" ­was in fact a part of Johnson's intimate circle of friends and advisers.


 * "These included the number-two man at the Israeli embassy, a close personal friend; the strongly pro-Israeli Rostow brothers, Walt and Eugene, who were part of the national security bureaucracy in the administration; Supreme Court Justice Abe Fortas; U.N. Ambassador Arthur Goldberg; and numerous others who all spent time with Johnson at the LBJ Ranch in Texas and had the personal access and the leisure time in an informal setting to talk with Johnson about their concern for Israel and to influence him heavily in favor of Israel. This circle had already begun to work on Johnson long before Israel's pre-emptive attack in 1967, so they were nicely placed to persuade Johnson to go along with it despite Johnson's fears of provoking the Soviet Union and becoming involved in a military conflict the U.S. was not prepared for."

Also see critique of The Power of Israel in the United States by William Bowles.

Books on the pro-Israel lobby
John J. Mearsheimer and Stephen M. Walt, The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2007).

Stephen Lendman writing in 2006 also notes that James Petras' "powerful new book" The Power of Israel in the United States is "a work of epic writing and essential reading documenting the enormous influence of the pro-Israeli Lobby on US policy in the Middle East."

Also see Petras' (2007) latest contribution to the debate Rulers and Ruled in the US Empire: Bankers, Zionists and Militants

According to progressive publisher Pluto Press, in September 2007, "Pluto books and the University of Michigan Press - our US distributor - came under attack by Stand With Us (a Zionist lobby group) who were objecting to the publication of Overcoming Zionism by Joel Kovel, which resulted in the book being withdrawn in the US. The vitriolic attack questioned the University's relationship with Pluto generally and denigrated Overcoming Zionism."

Think tanks
In October 2002, Jill Junnola wrote in Energy Compass that the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) describes itself on its website as "America's pro-Israel lobby".

Junnola wrote that "Other institutes of note are JINSA and the Washington Institute for Near East Policy--both seen as strongly tied to the Israel lobby--and the Middle East Forum (MEF). Though their budgets--mostly funded through private donations--do not come close to those of their bigger brothers, they hit above their weight when it comes to influence."

Another is the American Israel Education Foundation which sponsors "fact-finding" trips for many members of Congress.

Affiliated funders
"The overlap among members of foundations, think tanks and, increasingly, the Bush team, borders on the incestuous," Junnola wrote.


 * Allegheny Foundations
 * Carthage Foundations
 * Castle Rock Foundation
 * Charles G. Koch Foundation
 * Claude R. Lambe Foundation
 * David H. Koch Foundation
 * Earhart Foundation
 * John M. Olin Foundation
 * Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation
 * Sarah Scaife Foundation
 * Smith Richardson Foundation

Pro-Israel lobbying groups

 * American Israel Public Affairs Committee
 * American Jewish Committee
 * American Jewish Congress
 * Anti-Defamation League
 * Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council
 * Conference of Presidents of Major Jewish Organizations
 * Israel on Campus Coalition
 * Republican Jewish Coalition
 * Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America
 * Zionist Organization of America

Related SourceWatch articles

 * Hasbara
 * State terrorism
 * The Power of the Israel Lobby: Its Origins and Growth (2006)
 * The threat that dare not speak its name
 * J Street
 * Conservative Friends of Israel

External articles

 * Edward S. Herman, "The Pro-Israel Lobby," ZMag, July 1994.
 * Michael Massing, "The Israel Lobby," The Nation, May 23, 2002 (June 10, 2002 issue).
 * Kelley Beaucar Vlahos, "Pro-Israeli Lobby a Force to Be Reckoned With," Fox News, May 28, 2002.
 * Dennis Prager, "'Pro-Israel lobby' is not why America supports Israel," Sullivan-County.com, July 3, 2002.
 * Joel Beinin, "Pro-Israel Hawks and the Second Gulf War," Middle East Report, April 6, 2003.
 * "Pro-Israel lobby on Capitol Hill," BBC, May 8, 2003.
 * Thomas B. Edsall and Molly Moore, "Pro-Israel Lobby Has Strong Voice. AIPAC Is Embroiled in Investigation of Pentagon Leaks," Washington Post, September 5, 2004.
 * Jeffrey Goldberg, "Real Insiders. A pro-Israel lobby and an F.B.I. sting," The New Yorker, July 4, 2005.
 * Joseph Massad, "Blaming the lobby," Al-Ahram Weekly, March 23/24, 2006; CounterPunch, March 25/26, 2006.
 * Noam Chomsky, "The Israel Lobby?" ZNet, March 28, 2006. Also see response to Chomsky.
 * James Petras, "Noam Chomsky and the Pro-Israel Lobby: Fourteen Erroneous Theses," Axis of Logic, April 3, 2006.
 * Daniel Levy, Opinion: "So pro-Israel that it hurts. America and Israel," International Herald Tribune, April 4, 2006.
 * Norman G. Finkelstein, "The Israel Lobby: It's Not Either / Or," CounterPunch, May 1, 2006.
 * Charley Reese, "Two American Views. The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy. Keeping It Quiet," Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, May/June 2006.
 * Margaret O'Neill, "Pro-Israel lobby heavily influencing US policy, academics say," Lateline/ABC News (Australia), July 19, 2006.
 * James Petras, "The Pro-Israel Lobby and US Middle East Policy. The Score Card for 2007," Dissident Voice, May 14, 2007.
 * James Petras, Norman Finkelstein and Hagit Borer, "Debating the Primacy of The Pro-Israel Lobby. The Debate between James Petras adn Norman Finkelstein," ZMag, April 18, 2007.
 * "An Interview With Mearsheimer and Walt", You Tube (Institute of International Studies), September 26, 2007.
 * "America's pro-Israel lobby. Powerful, but not that powerful," The Economist, September 27, 2007.
 * Joachim Martillo, "Judonia Rising: The Israel Lobby and American Society", Self-published, A Working Paper.

External resources

 * Mitchell Bard, "The Israeli and Arab Lobbies," The Jewish Virtual Library.
 * Israel lobby in the United States, Wikipedia.
 * The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, Wikipedia.
 * Washington Report on Middle East Affairs.

Websites

 * Israel Lobby Watch, Electronic Intifada.